by Confederate » Tue Jul 24, 2018 10:43 pm
SonnyBlackstein wrote: ↑Tue Jul 24, 2018 10:06 pm
Fughedaboutit wrote: ↑Tue Jul 24, 2018 11:45 am
SILENT PARTNERZ wrote: ↑Tue Jul 24, 2018 7:40 am
We should not always throw ScottB out with the bath water fellas.
Over the years he has developed contacts in several areas. Tim White
in Providence is one of them...
While some may not like his writing style or think he is full of BS...I really don't think he just makes shit up. He gets it from somewhere...I mean speculation based on what he may have heard or been told is better than nothing IMO...Remember that he does have law enforcement contacts that some of you so highly tout
If we are going off the mob and pure fact on current affairs we would have nothing to talk about
Whilst he likely doesn't fabricate, his errors, non confirmation and general outright 'speculation' (refer example of Merlino giving the DePietro order) are so egregious and common that his trust-worthyness for 'journalism' is rendered almost completely useless.
The instances and examples are so numerous as to leave his work in the realm of simple speculation which is more oft than not proven false.
We read him because of his rarity in the field, not his quality or history of work.
And I WANT to believe him, but he's basically proven you do so at your own peril if youre looking for the truth.
Very well stated. In addition, the speculation, sensation and errors in the Chicago and Detroit articles are staggering. Yeh, I know, he's a nice guy blah, blah, blah... lol
[quote=SonnyBlackstein post_id=83840 time=1532495164 user_id=171]
[quote=Fughedaboutit post_id=83781 time=1532457926 user_id=5205]
[quote="SILENT PARTNERZ" post_id=83747 time=1532443240 user_id=5369]
We should not always throw ScottB out with the bath water fellas.
Over the years he has developed contacts in several areas. Tim White
in Providence is one of them...
[/quote]
While some may not like his writing style or think he is full of BS...I really don't think he just makes shit up. He gets it from somewhere...I mean speculation based on what he may have heard or been told is better than nothing IMO...Remember that he does have law enforcement contacts that some of you so highly tout
If we are going off the mob and pure fact on current affairs we would have nothing to talk about
[/quote]
Whilst he likely doesn't fabricate, his errors, non confirmation and general outright 'speculation' (refer example of Merlino giving the DePietro order) are so egregious and common that his trust-worthyness for 'journalism' is rendered almost completely useless.
The instances and examples are so numerous as to leave his work in the realm of simple speculation which is more oft than not proven false.
We read him because of his rarity in the field, not his quality or history of work.
And I WANT to believe him, but he's basically proven you do so at your own peril if youre looking for the truth.
[/quote]
Very well stated. In addition, the speculation, sensation and errors in the Chicago and Detroit articles are staggering. Yeh, I know, he's a nice guy blah, blah, blah... lol