by Tonyd621 » Thu Jun 05, 2025 8:36 pm
Camo wrote: ↑Thu Jun 05, 2025 6:27 pm
SonnyBlackstein wrote: ↑Thu Jun 05, 2025 6:23 pm
Camo wrote: ↑Thu Jun 05, 2025 6:00 pm
This is about Cicale being dismissed as a source on Nick Cirillo here yet being conveniently dragged out when it's about Scott. He's either credible or he isn't, is that an unreasoable ask?
Guess Im just an issues guy vs judgement guy.
Base every issue on its merits vs my opinion of the person.
I think Cicale is more likely to have clipped Cirillo than his father ordering it and I think Cicale is more likely to know if a bronx social club was robbed than Scott Burnstein.
I dont know why youre set on if you believe one you have to believe the other on totally unrelated issues.
You ever told a lie in your life? So I should never trust you on anything else you say ever? Of course not. You just base each issue on its merits.
Scott, still waiting on your merits buddy.
Fair enough i think that's a great way of looking at things.
I'm not set on anything i've explained my position. IMO Cicale would be more credible when he's an actual Soldier and especially when it's a situation he's a central figure in like Nick Cirillo, i'm not saying i look to Cicale on the Genovese leadership at that point, i'm saying that he had a conflict with Nick Cirillo and he later disappeared so i take him seriously on that issue. IMO he is far more credible on the life at that point than he is on what's going on in 2025.
Camo, you bring a good point. Cicale and his EG vodka. We all called him a bullshitter and a liar. I remember when Cicale said after he flipped he was doing construction projects with made guys and they didnt care because Dom was making money. And its got nothing to do with the Bronx. Imo and im just guessing, its because Dom used to be a bonanno. Also he has stated how much he dislikes Mancuso and tried to kill Mancuso. And he went on and on about his hatred for him. It was an easy opportunity for Cicale to jump on this and say "see, told, ya. Thats what I think...anyways.
[quote=Camo post_id=295179 time=1749173276 user_id=398]
[quote=SonnyBlackstein post_id=295178 time=1749172991 user_id=171]
[quote=Camo post_id=295174 time=1749171621 user_id=398]
This is about Cicale being dismissed as a source on Nick Cirillo here yet being conveniently dragged out when it's about Scott. He's either credible or he isn't, is that an unreasoable ask?
[/quote]
Guess Im just an issues guy vs judgement guy.
Base every issue on its merits vs my opinion of the person.
I think Cicale is more likely to have clipped Cirillo than his father ordering it and I think Cicale is more likely to know if a bronx social club was robbed than Scott Burnstein.
I dont know why youre set on if you believe one you have to believe the other on totally unrelated issues.
You ever told a lie in your life? So I should never trust you on anything else you say ever? Of course not. You just base each issue on its merits.
Scott, still waiting on your merits buddy.
[/quote]
Fair enough i think that's a great way of looking at things.
I'm not set on anything i've explained my position. IMO Cicale would be more credible when he's an actual Soldier and especially when it's a situation he's a central figure in like Nick Cirillo, i'm not saying i look to Cicale on the Genovese leadership at that point, i'm saying that he had a conflict with Nick Cirillo and he later disappeared so i take him seriously on that issue. IMO he is far more credible on the life at that point than he is on what's going on in 2025.
[/quote]
Camo, you bring a good point. Cicale and his EG vodka. We all called him a bullshitter and a liar. I remember when Cicale said after he flipped he was doing construction projects with made guys and they didnt care because Dom was making money. And its got nothing to do with the Bronx. Imo and im just guessing, its because Dom used to be a bonanno. Also he has stated how much he dislikes Mancuso and tried to kill Mancuso. And he went on and on about his hatred for him. It was an easy opportunity for Cicale to jump on this and say "see, told, ya. Thats what I think...anyways.