5 Family's Making Ceremonies

[Pete]

Bonnano's making so many guys recently just shows how bad they're struggling, it's the same with the Colombo's, it's like they'll make anyone.

Gambino's, Westside & luke's are more stable and selective.

Are they still requiring guys to make they're bones? I wonder how they're inducting 20 new guys with very few hits taking place

no they haven't been doing that for quite some time, it's more about earning.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

So that's only NY? Philly you still have to right? I feel like most of the guys made in recent years in philly had to make their bones still

[phatmatress]

Bonnano's making so many guys recently just shows how bad they're struggling, it's the same with the Colombo's, it's like they'll make anyone.

Gambino's, Westside & luke's are more stable and selective.

Are they still requiring guys to make they're bones? I wonder how they're inducting 20 new guys with very few hits taking place

no they haven't been doing that for quite some time, it's more about earning.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

So that's only NY? Philly you still have to right? I feel like most of the guys made in recent years in philly had to make their bones still

i don't believe every new recruit has a body under them. Although some newer ones like nicodemo were involved in some hits in the early 2000s when ligambi took over and cleaned house.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Pete]

Wasn't Dominic grande involved in a few hits too? Not sure about sonny mazzone or anthony borgesi

[phatmatress]

Borgesi was, he bragged to bent finger Lou many times about how to kill and how many he killed, he was involved in the 95 torture of Ralph mazzuca, and orchestrated the murder of joe sadano a captain who refused to fall in line with merlino in 96. Grande is thought to be involved with the diperero case that Anthony nicodemo just pled guilty to. Sonny has had some serious aggravated assault charges but I don't believe he has murdered.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[phatmatress]

Oh I'm sorry you said Anthony borgesi didn't see that lol


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Pogo The Clown]

It was a rule under Scarfo (at least for the Philly guy's, I don't think it applied to the North Jersey Crew) but I don't think it was a rule after that. However Philly has had so many murders over the last 25 years that most of the guy's made have by default been involved in a murder in some fashion.


Pogo

[Wiseguy]

Bonnano's making so many guys recently just shows how bad they're struggling, it's the same with the Colombo's, it's like they'll make anyone.

Gambino's, Westside & luke's are more stable and selective.

The NY families typically make new members to replace the ones that have died. It's not necessarily a sign of struggling. Back in the mid-1990's, the Genovese family reportedly made 30 new members over a 2 year period.

[B.]

It was a rule under Scarfo (at least for the Philly guy's, I don't think it applied to the North Jersey Crew) but I don't think it was a rule after that. However Philly has had so many murders over the last 25 years that most of the guy's made have by default been involved in a murder in some fashion.


Pogo

Yep, you've got it right about Philly/South Jersey members. I do think that the North Jersey members who were made before Scarfo's time possibly had murders under their belt (Luciano and Caponigro definitely did, and I assume DiNorscio and Napoli did as well), but not Licata, Attanasio, or the guys made in the invalidated ceremony. It's not clear to me if it was a rule in Philly before Scarfo, but I believe Phil Testa had the same philosophy and it actually might have applied under Bruno as well to a certain degree.

[johnny_scootch]

If the Bonanno's can make 21 guys in 2 years I can only imagine how many guys were made by families who actually have their shit together and haven't had any big cases in the last several years.
Looks like the NYC mafia is a long way from dying off. Plenty of guys out there who still want the button. On the conservative side say the other NY families only made half the amount as the Bonannos thats 60 newly made guys in last 2+ years. It's crazy if you try to imagine how many guys they might have made in the last 4, 6 or 8 years.

The Bonannos have been rebuilding, though, whereas the Genovese and Gambinos are larger and probably less desperate to recruit new members.

I believe the economic recession did a lot to help turn guys who were otherwise on the fence back toward the life. No info to back that up, but it seems likely enough to me.

It's true the Bonanno's have been rebuilding but historically the families like to keep some sort of balance between the size of the families so it's possible that all the families have ramped up recruitment in the last several years. In regards to I believe Tommys comment that the Bonanno's and Colombo's likely make anyone I would point out that Mike Mancuso's nephew who was said to be recently made is over 40 years of age and it seems to me that they are still making guys wait a long period of time before straightening them out. You don't see any 20 somethings made into NY families today. With all the rats both of these families have had you would think recruitment criteria has tightened up rather then loosened.

[TommyGambino]

Bonnano's making so many guys recently just shows how bad they're struggling, it's the same with the Colombo's, it's like they'll make anyone.

Gambino's, Westside & luke's are more stable and selective.

The NY families typically make new members to replace the ones that have died. It's not necessarily a sign of struggling. Back in the mid-1990's, the Genovese family reportedly made 30 new members over a 2 year period.

Source?

[TommyGambino]

If the Bonanno's can make 21 guys in 2 years I can only imagine how many guys were made by families who actually have their shit together and haven't had any big cases in the last several years.
Looks like the NYC mafia is a long way from dying off. Plenty of guys out there who still want the button. On the conservative side say the other NY families only made half the amount as the Bonannos thats 60 newly made guys in last 2+ years. It's crazy if you try to imagine how many guys they might have made in the last 4, 6 or 8 years.

The Bonannos have been rebuilding, though, whereas the Genovese and Gambinos are larger and probably less desperate to recruit new members.

I believe the economic recession did a lot to help turn guys who were otherwise on the fence back toward the life. No info to back that up, but it seems likely enough to me.

It's true the Bonanno's have been rebuilding but historically the families like to keep some sort of balance between the size of the families so it's possible that all the families have ramped up recruitment in the last several years. In regards to I believe Tommys comment that the Bonanno's and Colombo's likely make anyone I would point out that Mike Mancuso's nephew who was said to be recently made is over 40 years of age and it seems to me that they are still making guys wait a long period of time before straightening them out. You don't see any 20 somethings made into NY families today. With all the rats both of these families have had you would think recruitment criteria has tightened up rather then loosened.

It's always rare that someone get's made in there 20's throughout the history on LCN, only people I can think of being made really young in the last 20 years are legacies.

I might need to go back and read the Gangland article but I'm sure Capeci hinted at Mancuso's nephew being made to give him more stature as his messenger, I could be wrong.

[Wiseguy]

Bonnano's making so many guys recently just shows how bad they're struggling, it's the same with the Colombo's, it's like they'll make anyone.

Gambino's, Westside & luke's are more stable and selective.

The NY families typically make new members to replace the ones that have died. It's not necessarily a sign of struggling. Back in the mid-1990's, the Genovese family reportedly made 30 new members over a 2 year period.

Source?

From the 1995 article below (Page 25)

Law enforcement sources tell New York that the Genovese family has even "opened the books," initiating 30 new members within the last two years.

https://books.google.com/books?id=6uQCA ... ed&f=false


It may have been just a coincidence but you'll recall 30 members was how many open memberships Gotti reminded Chin he had yet to fill during their Commission meeting.

[johnny_scootch]

It's always rare that someone get's made in there 20's throughout the history on LCN

I agree that in the last 20 years it's been rare but in the history of Cosa Nostra I'd disagree, there is a very long list of guys made in there 20's if you mine it's entire history.

[Wiseguy]

On the point of the NY families making new members to replace those that have died, since 2000 I count...

75 Genovese members have died

53 Gambino members have died

35 Colombo members have died

34 Bonanno members have died

27 Lucchese members have died


Of course, these are the ones we know about. But going by those numbers, the Genovese would have had to make an average of 5 new members each year over that time frame to remain stable. The Gambinos average of 3-4 new members each year. The Colombos and Bonannos an average of 2-3 members each year. And the Luccheses an average of around 2 new members each year.

Considering there are members who have died we don't know about, the numbers are probably at least a little higher. But, going by the general estimates for the membership of each family, since 2000 the Genovese have had to replace nearly 40% of it's membership. The Gambinos at least 25%. The Colombos and Bonannos at least 35%. And the Luccheses nearly 30%.

Taking the 5 families together, nearly a third of the total membership alive in 2000 has died and would have had to be replaced over the past 15 years.

[Pogo The Clown]

We can add Anthony “Muzzy” Pucciarello, Paul Coppola and Louis “JR” Rizzo Jr. for a 2009 Genovese ceremony.


Pogo