by BeatiPaoli » Fri Mar 12, 2021 7:31 am
To Everyone: The subject of the "early mafias" and proto-mafias ( as I also refer to them) in Sicily is fascinating and quite interesting. In line with this subject matter, I have 2 tangentially related questions: did both the Beati Paoli in Sicily and the Garduna of Spain (the latter allegedly an organizational precursor to the Camorra of Naples) exist? The respected author and researcher John Dickie in "Blood Brotherhoods" (the 700 page edition) implied / alluded that neither or these organizations existed, and were just criminal myths (my wording). Yet, in Charles William Heckethorn's excellent compendium, "Secret Societies of All Ages", he offers evidence of their existence. I would like to hear what everyone has to say regarding this.
Regards,
BeatiPaoli
To Everyone: The subject of the "early mafias" and proto-mafias ( as I also refer to them) in Sicily is fascinating and quite interesting. In line with this subject matter, I have 2 tangentially related questions: did both the Beati Paoli in Sicily and the Garduna of Spain (the latter allegedly an organizational precursor to the Camorra of Naples) exist? The respected author and researcher John Dickie in "Blood Brotherhoods" (the 700 page edition) implied / alluded that neither or these organizations existed, and were just criminal myths (my wording). Yet, in Charles William Heckethorn's excellent compendium, "Secret Societies of All Ages", he offers evidence of their existence. I would like to hear what everyone has to say regarding this.
Regards,
BeatiPaoli