Antiliar
Some of the info you want just doesn't exist. I've been working on this for years and don't have all the answers and there is debate about the early history. First, let's say that Nick Gentile is correct that Capone was made a capodecina who reported to Joe Masseria with the right to make ten men. Like I wrote elsewhere, I have other sources that support this. Then what you have is a large crew that has these eleven people at its core, but with many more working under them. We don't know who the ten men were who Capone made, but we can guess. With this in mind I think if you made your starting point 1931 you would do better. However, there are some things I can tell you.
In Chicago Heights, the first Caponite leader there was Dominic Roberto from around 1926 to 1928 (he was deported), followed by Jimmy Emery until 1957.
Rocco De Grazia was the first leader that I'm aware of in Melrose Park, but have no starting date
Tony Capezio was earliest head of the Grand Avenue crew
Guzik was the first connection guy, but I don't know when that started
Louis Campagna might have been the first Cicero leader after Capone divided up the crews. Or it could have been Ralph Capone until he went to prison. Or it could have been Frank Nitti
Ricca probably headed up the earliest Taylor Street crew that later went to Fiore Buccieri. Contrary to most who claim that Nitti was the first boss, I believe it was Ricca.
What there is of DeGeorge in the FBI files says that he was the boss of the North Side crew before Prio, but it doesn't say for how long he was the boss or if there was anyone else before him. There are only bits and pieces of DeGeorge in other people's files because the FBI destroyed his file. Maybe Pinelli was a previous North Side boss, I don't know. Vincent Benevento may have been a caporegime too, or Phil D'Andrea. The FBI also has Willie "Potatoes" Daddano as a capo covering other counties with guys like Black Joe Amato and Pasquale Clementi under him. Jimmy Belcastro may have been an early capo. "Dago" Lawrence Mangano may have been one too.
Pogo, if you want to trace things earlier then you're going to the earlier groups:
-Chicago Heights was originally the Chicago Heights Mafia with bosses such as Tony San Filippo. Don't pay attention to that stupidity that came out Laurence Bergreen that Capone was working for Frank La Porte. That's just crazy. I recommend Matt Luzi's book on Chicago Heights. It's very good and accurate (there might be a point here and there I can debate, but overall it's highly recommended). There's another book on the Heights coming out soon that Luzi recommends, and it's longer and more detailed that Luzi's account.
-The North Side crew replaced the previous occupants -- the Aiellos
-Taylor Street covered Little Italy and its previous occupants were Joe Esposito, the Genna brothers and the heads of the Chicago Mafia
-Cicero was under John Torrio after Ed Vogel invited him and Capone in when Dever became mayor. It was run by Al Capone and his brothers, but they were working for Torrio until Spring of 1925
-Capone's people were the first organized criminals to operate in Melrose Park and Grand Avenue/Elmwood Park, so De Grazia and Capezio were the first ones there.
-Capone and Torrio at first operated out of the South Side because that's where Colosimo was. The crew that was closest to where Capone operated (out of the Lexington Hotel, or even earlier to Colosimo's Cafe) was the Taylor Street crew, so it's possible that there was an extra prestige to being part of this crew for that reason.
About Ferraro, I haven't seen where any informant identified him as an underboss, so I don't know how the FBI concluded that. One informant said he was actually the boss over Cicero between Campagna and Aiuppa. I found a section of dialogue with Ferraro and Giancana where they were discussing Aiuppa and that Ferraro was going to give him an order about something. It makes sense if he was the Cicero capo like the informant claimed then he would also be direct to Giancana -- as all the capos were. The fact that Ferraro operated out of the Loop isn't relevant considering that Campagna lived in Berrien County, Michigan (after he moved from Berwyn).
Regarding Daddano, several informants talked about him being very powerful but they never ascribed a rank to him. The FBI, however, lists him as the capo of DuPage, McHenry and Lake counties several times. It seems that if he had several made guys operating under him he would be the equivalent of a capo whether or not he had the title.
When Aiuppa was boss there was a #2 - Jack Cerone, and I think Rio and Nitti were Ricca's underbosses, followed by Accardo. When Ricca retired and Accardo was made boss he picked Giancana (there might have been some importance that both of their parents came from Castelvetrano) as his underboss -- which makes me wonder, was Giancana the Taylor Street capo before Buccieri?
From at least 1953 or earlier to when Accardo stepped down in 1956/57 Giancana was his underboss, so I was wondering if he was the Taylor Street capo before that. He was released from prison in 1942 and according to some sources was made before he went to prison in 1939. So if he was a capo it wasn't for very long before he became Accardo's underboss. Accardo became boss in 1947.
On Ferraro, I wasn't going by Roemer's book but by the actual transcripts, and in those transcripts it looks like Ferraro was going to give Aiuppa an order.
Cavita
Frank LaPorte (real name Liparota) was put in charge of slots and handbooks in the Heights by Jim Emery. LaPorte took over as boss in 1957 but I don't think he was anything but a soldier before then. And yes, Emery's real name was Vincenzo Ammirati and he was Calabrian
Pogo
So a rough breakdown for the late 20s/early 30s would look like this.
Boss: Al Capone
UnderBoss/#2: Frank Nitti?
Connection Guy's: Jake Guzik
Street Crews:
Taylor Street: Paul Ricca (possibly)
Melrose Park: Rocco DeGrazia (possibly)
Grand Avenue: Tony Capezio
Cicero: Louis Campagna or Ralph Capone. Possibly Frank Nitti before that.
Chicago Heights: Domenico Roberto (1926-1928) followed by Jimmy Emery (Wasn't his real name Vincenzo Ammeratto?)
Checking my records I have a Bruno "The Bomber" Roti being the Crew Boss over Chinatown/26th Street in the 20s and 30s and Frank LaPorte as Capone's top advisor from 1928-1931? Is any of this accurate?
Chicago
Agree with everything you said except Daddano. It's true he was a very powerful made guy. He was first among equals with the made guys or upper management.
However, at the end of the day, Willie was under Battaglia. He was out in DuPage County but was with Battaglia.
I believe he was so prominent for awhile (before he went to jail in the 1960's) that the Feds believed he was a Boss (Capo) they also believed this of Chuckie English because he was direct with Giancana. they also believed this of Ferraro who was also direct with Giancana. These guys were strong made guys who ran their own Sub crews and were very prominent.
However, there were only about 6 crews and Daddano and English were not Bosses of any of these 6 and Ferraro was not the #2. I asked my uncle about Ferraro when Roemer's book came out just like I asked him about the 1983 Chart, and He told me specifically that Daddano was under Battaglia and that Ferraro was not the #2.
It was actually Battaglia. That's why when Giancana left, Battaglia became the Top Boss. Make sense?
Ovid Demaris, Who wrote a very good Book called Captive City, said the same thing.
Side note: There really was no official #2 because the top three were Ricca, Accardo & Giancana.
However, in terms of Practicality and Power, Battaglia was the UNOFFICIAL #2 and was next in line to be Top Boss which is exactly what happened when Giancana left.
Absolutely 100% yes. Giancana was the Boss (Capo) of Taylor St. before 1957. Then, in 1957, Bucciere became Capo of Taylor St. But, remember the Chicago formula, Bucciere & Battaglia assisted Giancana in running both the Taylor St. & Melrose Park Crews, All those guys were HIS guys at the end of the day. That's why Daddano, Nicoletti, Alderisio, etc. were all in direct contact with both Batttaglia & Giancana. Giancana kept his Taylor St. men very close to him.
Ferraro was never the Capo (Boss) of Cicero with made guys and soldier/associates under him.
No, it was Auippa for a VERY long time. In Roemer's Book, Giancana is talking to Ferraro ABOUT Auippa and is telling him that if Auippa can't do better in Cicero, then he can't do better anywhere because Cicero is a great area.
It was more like Shop talk.
Also, Giancana could pass an order through any made guy who was one of his Taylor St. men or one of the other made guys direct with him to somebody else in the Outfit.
Many times an order would come from Chuckie English to the Elmwood Park Crew about the Juke Box Machines that Gagliano and English were involved with together. It would NOT be English giving the order, it would be English PASSING the order to Cerone or Gagliano. Big difference.
How do I know? because My uncle was also a Juke Box Machine Collector along with being a Juice Collector.
Ferraro PASSING an order to Auippa is what happened. Ferraro was direct with Giancana and had been direct with Accardo & Ricca previously. The guys working in Ferraro & Alex's sub crew were not considered made guys. They were ordinary Bookmaking guys. Ferraro was a political guy similar to Marcy, except he didn't have an office right in the middle of everything like Marcy.
Again, just because a guy like Marcy or Ferraro or English PASS an order along, doesn't make them a Capo or an Underboss.
Giancana was the Boss of Taylor St. all by himself from 1942 to 1947.
In 1947, he became the #2, but was still the Boss of Taylor St. with Bucciere as his personal underboss.
In 1957, Giancan became #1, but was still the Boss of Taylor St. and Melrose Park with Bucciere and Battaglia as his personal underbosses.
Melrose Park Crew at that time was just another extension of the Taylor St. Power Base.
If you stop and think about it, and do not equate it to New York, you will see it very clearly.
The #1 & the #2 NEVER give up their Crew completely to someone.
That's why in 1992, when they indicted Carlisi, Marcello etc. They called it the Sam Carlisi Street crew even though he was the #1. See the point?