Palermo was the port city and it was Palermitans who were among the first Sicilians to arrive. Sciacca likely a close second. Followed with or by Trapani.B. wrote: ↑Tue Apr 20, 2021 4:34 pm The problem is that even the Corleonesi being the "first" has become its own folklore, but in that case with outsiders. I've never actually seen an account from a mafia member who thinks men from Corleone formed the "first family" and as more evidence comes out, it becomes clear they were an important faction/network that produced leaders and a boss of bosses, but they weren't the first nor only show in town.
It also depends on the POV. There is the source connected to St. Louis / Detroit who said the men from the Favarotta neighborhood of Terrasini were the most dominant group of paesani in all the mafia, and they are right this group formed an important leadership class, especially in those midwest cities, but outside of Detroit and St. Louis you weren't going to hear anyone putting it that way. If this informant was our only source, we'd probably think men from Terrasini were more influential in mafia history than they were (and they were still highly influential anyway).
Another question mark in early DeCavalcante history is Frank Rizzo DeCavalcante. On the DeCavalcante tapes, Sam implies his father was responsible for inducting some of the old time members. We know from a comment on the DeCarlo tapes that the elder DeCavalcante held the rank of capodecina, so he may have been a ranking member for decades before he died, making him the earliest known DeCavalcante member to hold the rank of captain or higher. The Rizzo DeCavalantes were from Monreale/Palermo and lived in Westfield, near Elizabeth, so Frank may have joined this family because of where he lived in New Jersey or maybe there was an early Palermitani element in the family that is lost to time.
Anyways, between this and our other conversations it made me contact DiLeonardo and ask him about D'Aquila/first boss and whether he was told that or its something he heard of later and turns out, he was told that. But as he explains it, he was told that in the context of there being no one before him who wielded the type of power D'Aquila had, he didn't interpret it as them saying D'Aquila founded the Gambino Family.
If in the year 1920 there was some national consolidation of groups into larger Families, that happened under D'Aquila's watch. Combined with the fact that NY remained five families rather than 20 (the numbers would have justified that amount) is a lasting result of D'Aquila's reign, even if it was by design or indifference.
And again, six months after "D'Aquila is in a war against Lo Monte, Mineo and Schiro" Lo Monte was killed and multiple sources (Gentile, Clemente) both stated that no one knew who did it. There's more to this story but stopping right here, it's amazing and speaks to the potential diplomatic prowess that D'Aquila had for a rival to be murdered half a year later and the power to squash anyone to openly accuse him of it.
Anyway, we're back to square one regarding this Jersey business.