I agree it seems more likely that Grande was promised a captain position in a Philadelphia family under the Scarfos and I also think that Persiano and Piccolo were inducted as part of the Luchese-recognised, Scarfo-headed version of the Philadelphia family. (Probably being brought into the fold under Merlino when Scarfo and Pelullo were jailed 2011 or convicted later).
Discussing the ceremony in a 2019 Mob Talk (which is now no longer available to view on the YouTube channel for some reason), Dave Schratwieser noted that it took place about 10 years prior. Schratwieser fist claimed it was a Luchese ceremony but Anastasia corrected him that it wasn't necessarily the Lucheses. We know that Persiano, Piccolo, Salvatore Pelullo and another individual were made with Scarfo Sr's blessing. The inductions were a reward for their involvement in the FirstPlus scam and the ceremony was conducted by an "old timer".
This could also mean that Pelullo and the other unidentified inductee were taken in by Philadelphia like Persiano and Piccolo were or perhaps Pelullo's incarceration left him in a no-man's land or with the Lucheses.
In terms of the timeline:
- Scarfo Jr relocated to South Jersey in 2006/ 2007
- He was then demoted from capo to soldier in the Luchese family in August 2007 partially due to reports that he was positioning to take over Philadelphia
- However, an affidavit stated that the Scarfos had the backing of some of the New York families to take Philadelphia back (it did not say which families)
- Search warrants were issued May 2008 relating to the FirstPlus investigation
- Scarfo was indicted and released on bail May 2010 in a Luchese gambling case
- Indictments in the FirstPlus case hit Nov 2011, with Scarfo and Pelullo being denied bail
- The ceremony then had to take place probably around 2007 or 2008 (at the height of FirstPlus activity) or at the very latest by 2011
In terms of who the other inductee was I have a couple of thoughts here:
Daniel Daidone:
- Associated with Scarfo Jr between Feb 2007 and May 2008, which was the height of FirstPlus activity
- Talked with Scarfo Sr on the phone during this time
- Jailed for parole violation Sep 2008
John Parisi:
- Scarfo's cousin
- Involved with FirstPlus and indicted with Scarfo and Pelullo in 2011
I also thought about who the "old timer" was who conducted the ceremony. I've assumed this to mean a long-time Philly member and, while it's true that Scarfo Jr approached Joseph Ciancaglini Jr about getting back involved I don't think he'd be counted as an "old timer".
"Old timers" who were still alive around that time:
Guerino Marconi:
- Seems unlikely due to his having fallen out with Scarfo long before
- Died Feb 2009 and we don't have an exact date for the ceremony so he might not have even been alive still
Anthony Pungitore Sr:
- Also unlikely as the Pungitores were identified by Philly PD as being aligned with Merlino and Ligambi by the late-2000s
Mario Maggio:
- Seems less likely due to how little we heard about him from the 80s on in terms of involvement
Domenic Rugnetta:
- Same reason as Maggio
Francis Iannarella Sr:
- Seems unlikely, seeing how Iannarella Jr easily aligned himself with the family when he got off supervised release
Joseph Costello:
- Also unlikely as he died 2007 so there would be little overlap in terms of when the ceremony could take place
John Praino:
- Out of all the possibilities seems the most likely
- Still identified as active in the 2000s (
viewtopic.php?f=44&t=4795)
- Had ties to the Scarfos through the North Jersey crew in the 1980s and 1990s
I agree it seems more likely that Grande was promised a captain position in a Philadelphia family under the Scarfos and I also think that Persiano and Piccolo were inducted as part of the Luchese-recognised, Scarfo-headed version of the Philadelphia family. (Probably being brought into the fold under Merlino when Scarfo and Pelullo were jailed 2011 or convicted later).
Discussing the ceremony in a 2019 Mob Talk (which is now no longer available to view on the YouTube channel for some reason), Dave Schratwieser noted that it took place about 10 years prior. Schratwieser fist claimed it was a Luchese ceremony but Anastasia corrected him that it wasn't necessarily the Lucheses. We know that Persiano, Piccolo, Salvatore Pelullo and another individual were made with Scarfo Sr's blessing. The inductions were a reward for their involvement in the FirstPlus scam and the ceremony was conducted by an "old timer".
This could also mean that Pelullo and the other unidentified inductee were taken in by Philadelphia like Persiano and Piccolo were or perhaps Pelullo's incarceration left him in a no-man's land or with the Lucheses.
In terms of the timeline:
- Scarfo Jr relocated to South Jersey in 2006/ 2007
- He was then demoted from capo to soldier in the Luchese family in August 2007 partially due to reports that he was positioning to take over Philadelphia
- However, an affidavit stated that the Scarfos had the backing of some of the New York families to take Philadelphia back (it did not say which families)
- Search warrants were issued May 2008 relating to the FirstPlus investigation
- Scarfo was indicted and released on bail May 2010 in a Luchese gambling case
- Indictments in the FirstPlus case hit Nov 2011, with Scarfo and Pelullo being denied bail
- The ceremony then had to take place probably around 2007 or 2008 (at the height of FirstPlus activity) or at the very latest by 2011
In terms of who the other inductee was I have a couple of thoughts here:
Daniel Daidone:
- Associated with Scarfo Jr between Feb 2007 and May 2008, which was the height of FirstPlus activity
- Talked with Scarfo Sr on the phone during this time
- Jailed for parole violation Sep 2008
John Parisi:
- Scarfo's cousin
- Involved with FirstPlus and indicted with Scarfo and Pelullo in 2011
I also thought about who the "old timer" was who conducted the ceremony. I've assumed this to mean a long-time Philly member and, while it's true that Scarfo Jr approached Joseph Ciancaglini Jr about getting back involved I don't think he'd be counted as an "old timer".
"Old timers" who were still alive around that time:
Guerino Marconi:
- Seems unlikely due to his having fallen out with Scarfo long before
- Died Feb 2009 and we don't have an exact date for the ceremony so he might not have even been alive still
Anthony Pungitore Sr:
- Also unlikely as the Pungitores were identified by Philly PD as being aligned with Merlino and Ligambi by the late-2000s
Mario Maggio:
- Seems less likely due to how little we heard about him from the 80s on in terms of involvement
Domenic Rugnetta:
- Same reason as Maggio
Francis Iannarella Sr:
- Seems unlikely, seeing how Iannarella Jr easily aligned himself with the family when he got off supervised release
Joseph Costello:
- Also unlikely as he died 2007 so there would be little overlap in terms of when the ceremony could take place
John Praino:
- Out of all the possibilities seems the most likely
- Still identified as active in the 2000s (http://theblackhand.club/forum/viewtopic.php?f=44&t=4795)
- Had ties to the Scarfos through the North Jersey crew in the 1980s and 1990s